Free-ish/Reasonable/Fancy Pants: New York ZA for Every Budget 🍕

New York City is famous for many things, but nothing defines it quite like New York pizza. Some say it’s the water that makes it special. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice between subway stops or sitting down for a gourmet pie, NYC has pizza for every budget.

If you’re wondering where to find the best pizza in New York, this guide breaks it down into three simple categories: free-ish, reasonable, and fancy pants.

Free-ish: 2 Bros. Pizza (Multiple Locations)

If you search “cheap pizza NYC,” 2 Bros. always comes up — and for good reason. Their dollar slice legacy is part of New York culture. You get a large, foldable slice with gooey cheese and a crisp crust for about the price of a subway ride (depending on whether or not the MTA changes prices)

Reasonable: Rubirosa

For a sit-down experience that still feels accessible, Rubirosa’s thin crust pizzas, like the Supreme or vodka pie, hit the perfect balance of delicious and reasonably priced. It’s classic American-Italian with a little bit of flair.

Fancy Pants: L’Industrie Pizzeria

Regularly ranked among the best pizza spots in NYC, L’Industrie elevates the slice with high quality ingredients. Their burrata slice and fig-jam-and-bacon options are standouts. Expect a line and expect it to be worth it.